One Tree Hillpremiered 21 years ago in September 2003 on the WB, and quickly managed to capture the attention and hearts of countless viewers. The show, created by Mark Schwahn, told the story of two half-brothers, Lucas and Nathan, in the small fictional town of Tree Hill. Like many young adult dramas, the heart of the show was in the relationships between the characters.

Along with the brothers, you had Brooke, Peyton, and Haley rounding out the main cast. The thing that kept viewers coming back week after week was the rivalry between Lucas and Nathan, the friendships of Brooke and Peyton as well as Haley and Lucas, and the many complicated and tangled romantic relationships that occurred and shifted throughout the show’s 9 seasons.

A custom image of the One Tree Hill cast

What Was One Tree Hill About?

The show starts with Lucas joining the high school basketball team, the Tree Hill Ravens. His talent as a player, along with Lucas’ romantic interest in Nathan’s girlfriend, Peyton Sawyer, is what begins the rivalry between the two half-brothers. It is this complex conflict and the relationships between these characters, as well as with Peyton’s best friend Brooke and Lucas’ best friend Haley, that is the main focus of the first season.

Although relationships shift and change, and the characters go through amyriad of life-changing eventsthroughout the nine years the show aired, the focus remained on the core group and how their friendships grow and change with them. Viewers tuned in every week to see how their favorite characters were dealing with life, what challenges they would face, and if their favorite ships would get (or sometimes stay) together. In a television landscape that was becoming increasingly inundated with shows focused on mysteries, action, and crime stories, fans ofOne Tree Hillfound its simplicity, realism, and focus on the coming of age of normal teenagers in a small town refreshing.

One Tree Hill

How Will the Story Continue in the Sequel?

Given the show’s focus on the importance of friends and how your close friends can become part of your family – seeing you through the hardest times of your life, helping you heal and grow, and being there to celebrate the greatest times – it was unsurprising thatthe departure of Lucas and Peyton after the 6th season had a profound impact on fans.Their absence was felt by the viewers and the characters within the show alike, and some viewers even stopped watching because, to them, it felt like the show had lost something irreplaceable when these two characters left.

One Tree Hill was one of the most popular television shows, but why? Was it truly special or just something good in the moment?

When thesequel series forOne Tree Hillwas announced, there was a mixture of hope and disappointment among the fans.The sequel is being created and produced by Sophia Bush and Hilarie Burton, the actresses who portrayed Brooke and Peyton respectively, which has fans optimistic.With Burton and Bush leading the new series, there is a lot of possibility, and it’s clear that these two actresses have a lot of passion and appreciation for the original series. And with their years of experience portraying their characters and familiarity with the show, there’s a lot of confidence that these women will be able to make the return ofOne Tree Hillsomething special.

The cast of One Tree Hill

What Questions Are Fans Left With?

Shortly after the sequel series was announced, however, reports came out that a fewkey actors would not be returning.Although Peyton and Brooke will be back, the same cannot be said for Lucas and Haley – two of the main characters from the original show, and vital members of the core group of friends.Chad Michael Murrayand Bethany Joy Lenz, the actors behind the characters, have expressed that they will not be returning to reprise their roles. The absence of two such central figures in the original series who are so interconnected with the rest of the characters leaves fans with a lot of questions.

If Lucas is absent, what does that mean for him and Peyton?Are they still together, and if so, how will the show explain his absence? Is it possible that they’ll do what many other shows and movies have done when an actor wants to leave or won’t return, and kill his character off? This last possibility in particular could be very concerning for fans, as Lucas is something of a favorite among fans.Similar questions remain about Haley,who was close friends with everyone in the group and was Nathan Scott’s wife and the mother of his son, Jamie. The way that all the main characters are so intertwined with one another, and the fact that the relationships and friendships are truly the heart of the show, means that any absences will be deeply felt by the fans.

One Tree Hill

Best Chad Michael Murray Performances, Ranked

Chad Michael Murray is a successful actor who was a major heartthrob of the 2000s, having first skyrocketed to fame on the teen drama One Tree Hill.

With Lucas and Haley not being in the show, there are a lot of questions about what that means for their partners, their kids, and the friend group as a whole. There’s a chance that with two of the core group missing, the show won’t be the same and the dynamics will feel off for fans. A further question that fans were left with after the news of Murray and Lenz not reprising their roles, iswho else might not be coming back.

So far, there has been no confirmation of whether James Lafferty, who played Nathan Scott, will be returning. If neither Lucas nor Nathan are in the sequel series, it could feel to fans that something vital is missing, since they were, arguably, the two main characters among the group in the original show. And, either way, with the absence of Lucas, that central brother relationship will be missing from the new show, which could be a problem for viewers.